Most CSC Academic All-Americans
(NCAA Division I Institutions; as of January 2024)
Nebraska - 354
Stanford - 347
Notre Dame - 278
Alabama - 230
Penn State - 229
CSC Academic All-Americans
All-Time CSC Academic All-Americans
| Name | Position | CSC Team | Team |
| Joe Bellas | T | Football | --- |
| John Runnells | LB | Football | --- |
| John Runnells | LB | Football | 1st |
| Rich Buzin | OT | Football | --- |
| Dennis Onkotz | LB | Football | --- |
| Charlie Pittman | OHB | Football | --- |
| Bruce Bannon | DE | Football | 2nd |
| Gary Gray | LB | Football | 2nd |
| Dave Joyner | OT | Football | 1st |
| Bruce Bannon | DE | Football | 1st |
| Mark Markovich | OG | Football | 2nd |
| Kevin Burke | --- | Men's Basketball | 2nd |
| Douglas Allen | LB | Football | 2nd |
| Jack Balorunos | DC | Football | 2nd |
| Mark Markovich | OG | Football | 1st |
| Dan Natale | OE | Football | 2nd |
| Kevin Maronic | P | Baseball | 2nd |
| Chris Bahr | KS | Football | 2nd |
| John Quinn | DT | Football | 2nd |
| Kurt Allerman | LB | Football | 2nd |
| Chuck Benjamin | OT | Football | 1st |
| George Weigel | C | Baseball | 1st |
| Keith Dorney | OT | Football | 1st |
| Scott Fitzkee | WR | Football | 2nd |
| Mike Gusman | RB | Football | 2nd |
| John Walsh | DB | Football | 2nd |
| Todd Blackledge | QB | Football | 1st |
| Harry Hamilton | DB | Football | 1st |
| Scott Radicec | LB | Football | 1st |
| Mark Robinson | DB | Football | 2nd |
| Mary Ann Cremo | OF | Softball | 1st |
| Harry Hamilton | LB | Football | --- |
| Scott Radicec | LB | Football | 2nd |
| Lance Hamilton | DB | Football | 1st |
| Carmen Masciantonio | LB | Football | 1st |
| Lance Hamilton | DB | Football | 1st |
| James Martin | Wrestling | Men's At-Large | 1st |
| John Shaffer | QB | Football | 1st |
| Brian Siverling | TE | Football | 2nd |
| Vida Kirnich | H | Women's Volleyball | 2nd |
| Joel Coleman | Track & Field | Men's At-Large | 1st |
| James Martin | Wrestling | Men's At-Large | 1st |
| Vicki Link | F | Women's Basketball | 2nd |
| James Martin | Wrestling | Men's At-Large | 1st |
| Rebecca Vaughan | Lacrosse | Women's At-Large | 2nd |
| Kenneth Chertow | Wrestling | Men's At-Large | 1st |
| James Martin | Wrestling | Men's At-Large | 1st |
| Rebecca Vaughan | Lacrosse | Women's At-Large | 1st |
| Tim Witham | Swimming | Men's At-Large | 1st |
| Pam Connell | Track & Field | Women's At-Large | 3rd |
| Susan Robinson | FC | Women's Basketball | 2nd |
| Susan Robinson | FC | Women's Basketball | 1st |
| Dave Hart | Wrestling | Men's At-Large | 2nd |
| Jenny Kretchmar | G | Women's Basketball | 3rd |
| Craig Fayak | K | Football | 2nd |
| Byron Schneider | Volleyball | Men's At-Large | 1st |
| John Amaechi | FC | Men's Basketball | 1st |
| Kim Kelly | Track & Field | Women's At-Large | 2nd |
| Jeff Hartings | OL | Football | 1st |
| Tony Pittman | DB | Football | 1st |
| Zeynep Ton | --- | Women's Volleyball | 1st |
| John Amaechi | --- | Men's Basketball | 1st |
| Olga Kalinovskaya-Ritterbush | Fencing | Women's At-Large | 1st |
| Kristine Kelly | Track & Field | Women's At-Large | 3rd |
| Kimarie Kelly | Track & Field | Women's At-Large | 3rd |
| Missy Masley | --- | Women's Basketball | 3rd |
| Zeynep Ton | OH | Women's Basketball | 1st |
| Jeff Hartings | OL | Football | 1st |
| Ivan Contreras | Volleyball | Men's At-Large | 2nd |
| Olga Kalinovskaya-Ritterbush | Fencing | Women's At-Large | 1st |
| Travis Berger | Soccer | Men's At-Large | 3rd |
| Stuart Reid | Soccer | Men's At-Large | 1st |
| Carl Albrecht | IF | Baseball | 3rd |
| Jared Sadlowski | C | Baseball | 1st |
| Ivan Contreras | Volleyball | Men's At-Large | 1st |
| Joe Roemer | Gymnastics | Men's At-Large | 2nd |
| Pete Lisicky | G | Men's Basketball | 2nd |
| Becky Gusic | Track & Field | Women's At-Large | 1st |
| Kim McGreevy | Cross Country | Women's At-Large | 2nd |
| James Cook | Golf | Men's At-Large | 2nd |
| Pete Lisicky | G | Men's Basketball | 2nd |
| Bonnie Bremner | S | Women's Volleyball | 1st |
| Lauren Cacciamani | MH | Women's Volleyball | 1st |
| Dan Beers | OF | Baseball | 3rd |
| Tony Mazzullo | Volleyball | Men's At-Large | 2nd |
| Glenn Pritzlaff | Wrestling | Men's At-Large | 2nd |
| Dan Earl | G | Men's Basketball | 3rd |
| Ellen Casey | Gymnastics | Women's At-Large | 3rd |
| Jaime Jaax | Swimming | Women's At-Large | 2nd |
| Melissa Uglow | Track & Field | Women's At-Large | 3rd |
| Jordan Caruso | OL | Football | 2nd |
| Travis Forney | PK | Football | 1st |
| Bonnie Bremner | S | Women's Volleyball | 1st |
| Lauren Cacciamani | MH | Women's Volleyball | 1st |
| Greg Marshalek | Golf | Men's At-Large | 3rd |
| Karen Gulini | OF | Softball | 2nd |
| Carla Esteva | Fencing | Women's At-Large | 2nd |
| Andrea Garner | C | Women's Basketball | 3rd |
| Jordan Caruso | OL | Football | 2nd |
| Mike Derenso | IF | Baseball | 1st |
| Chris Netwall | C | Baseball | 3rd |
| Jose Palacios | Gymnastics | Men's At-Large | 2nd |
| Karen Gulini | OF | Softball | 2nd |
| Allison Medellin | IF | Softball | 1st |
| Catherine Anderson | Swimming | Women's At-Large | 1st |
| Traci Anselmo | Field Hockey | Women's At-Large | 2nd |
| Emily Oleksiuk | Soccer | Women's At-Large | 2nd |
| Joanna Lohman | M | Women's Soccer | 1st |
| Emily Oleksiuk | GK | Women's Soccer | 1st |
| Mike DeRenzo | IF | Baseball | 1st |
| Tyler Smith | --- | Men's Basketball | 3rd |
| Stephanie Eim | Fencing | Women's At-Large | 1st |
| Kelly Mazzante | G | Women's Basketball | 3rd |
| Joe Iorio | OL | Football | 1st |
| Joanna Lohman | M | Women's Soccer | 1st |
| Christie Welsh | F | Women's Soccer | 2nd |
| Mike DeRenzo | IF | Baseball | 3st |
| Zeljko Koljesar | Volleyball | Men's At-Large | 2nd |
| Kelly Mazzante | G | Women's Basketball | 2nd |
| Dave Costlow | OL | Football | 2nd |
| Joanna Lohman | F | Women's Soccer | 1st |
| Clint Keithley | Tennis | Men's At-Large | 1st |
| Kelly Mazzante | G | Women's Basketball | 1st |
| Andrew Guman | DB | Football | 1st |
| Keith Kowal | Volleyball | Men's At-Large | 1st |
| Deidre Dlugonski | Swimming | Women's At-Large | 1st |
| Paul Posluszny | LB | Football | 1st |
| Conrad Taylor | GK | Men's Soccer | 2nd |
| Lindsay Bach | D | Women's Soccer | 1st |
| Erin McLeod | GK | Women's Soccer | 3rd |
| Sarah Haupt | --- | Women's At-Large | 2nd |
| Jennifer Leatherman | --- | Women's Track/XC | 1st |
| Nolan Mccready | DB | Football | 2nd |
| Paul Posluszny | LB | Football | 1st |
| Tim Shaw | DL | Football | 1st |
| Ryan Badaracco | D | Men's Soccer | 3rd |
| Conrad Taylor | GK | Men's Soccer | 3rd |
| Aubrey Aden-Buie | F | Women's Soccer | 3rd |
| Molly Crispell | Swimming | Women's At-Large | 2nd |
| Stephanie Sullivan | Gymnastics | Women's At-Large | 3rd |
| Gerald Cadogan | OL | Football | 1st |
| Aubrey Aden-Buie | F | Women's Soccer | 2nd |
| Zoe Bouchelle | MF | Women's Soccer | 3rd |
| Christa Harmotto | --- | Women's Volleyball | 3rd |
| Max Lipsitz | Volleyball | Men's At-Large | 2nd |
| Molly Crispell | Swimming | Women's At-Large | 1st |
| Gerald Cadogan | OL | Football | 1st |
| Josh Hull | LB | Football | 1st |
| Andrew Pitz | OL | Football | 1st |
| Mark Rubin | DB | Football | 1st |
| Stefen Wisniewski | OL | Football | 2nd |
| Ryan Badaracco | M | Men's Soccer | 1st |
| Zoe Bouchelle | M | Women's Soccer | 3rd |
| Christa Harmotto | --- | Women's Volleyball | 1st |
| Megan Hodge | --- | Women's Volleyball | 2nd |
| Paul Cianciola | P | Baseball | 2nd |
| Bridget Franek | --- | Women's Track/XC | 3rd |
| Josh Hull | LB | Football | 1st |
| Andrew Pitz | OL | Football | 1st |
| Stefen Wisniewski | OL | Football | 1st |
| Jason Yeisley | F | Men's Soccer | 1st |
| Megan Hodge | --- | Women's Volleyball | 1st |
| David Lutz | P | Baseball | 3rd |
| Max Lipsitz | --- | Men's At-Large | 2nd |
| Ashley Griffith | OF | Softball | 3rd |
| Brandi Personett | --- | Women's At-Large | 2nd |
| Bridget Franek | --- | Women's Track/XC | 2nd |
| Chris Colasanti | LB | Football | 1st |
| Pete Massaro | DL | Football | 1st |
| Stefen Wisniewski | OL | Football | 1st |
| Miguel Pineda | Gymnastics | Men's At-Large | 1st |
| Ryan Foster | --- | Men's Track/XC | 1st |
| Maya Hayes | --- | Women's Soccer | 3rd |
| Miguel Pineda | --- | Men's At-Large | 1st |
| Pete Massaro | DL | Football | 1st |
| John Urschel | OL | Football | 1st |
| Julian Cardona | F | Men's Soccer | 3rd |
| Kelsey Amy | --- | Women's At-Large | 3rd |
| Matt Brown | Wrestling | Men's At-Large | 1st |
| Robby Creese | --- | Men's Track/XC | 3rd |
| Tatum Coffey | Lacrosse | Women's At-Large | 3rd |
| John Urschel | OL | Football | 1st |
| Kelsey Amy | Field Hockey | Women's At-Large | 2nd |
| Katie Slay | --- | Women's Volleyball | 1st |
| David Taylor | Wrestling | Men's At-Large | 1st |
| Gabrielle Shishkoff | Swimming | Women's At-Large | 3rd |
| Matt Brown | Wrestling | Men's At-Large | 1st |
| Robby Creese | --- | Men's Track/XC | 3rd |
| Tyler Yazujian | OL | Football | 2nd |
| Laura Gebhart | Field Hockey | Women's At-Large | 1st |
| Haleigh Washington | --- | Women's Volleyball | 2nd |
| Nico Mega!udis | Wrestling | Men's At-Large | 1st |
| Zain Retherford | Wrestling | Men's At-Large | 2nd |
| Tyler Yazujian | OL | Football | 1st |
| Haleigh Washington | --- | Women's Volleyball | 3rd |
| Jason Nolf | Wrestling | Men's At-Large | 2nd |
| Zain Retherford | Wrestling | Men's At-Large | 1st |
| Laura Bowman | Ice Hockey | Women's At-Large | 2nd |
| Emily Ogle | M | Women's Soccer | 2nd |
| Haleigh Washington | --- | Women's Volleyball | 2nd |
| Noah Roberson | Gymnastics | Men's At-Large | 1st |
| Blake Gillikin | P | Football | 1st |
| Kerry Abello | M | Women's Soccer | 2nd |
| Emily Ogle | M | Women's Soccer | 2nd |
| Noah Roberson | Gymnastics | Men's At-Large | 1st |
| Blake Gillikin | p | Football | 1st |
| Kerry Abello | M | Women's Soccer | 1st |
| Pierre Reedy | M | Men's Soccer | 1st |
| Kerry Abello | D | Women's Soccer | 1st |
| Sam Coffey | M | Women's Soccer | 1st |
| Frankie Tagliaferri | M | Women's Soccer | 3rd |
| Jack Baldwin | Gymnastics | Men's At-Large | 1st |
| Nick Lee | Wrestling | Men's At-Large | 2nd |
| Pierre Reedy | M | Men's Soccer | 3rd |
| Kerry Abello | D | Women's Soccer | 1st |
| Sam Coffey | M | Women's Soccer | 1st |
| Makenna Marisa | G | Women's Basketball | 3rd |
| Matt Wood | C | Baseball | 3rd |
| Max Dean | Wrestling | Men's At-Large | 3rd |
| Nick Lee | Wrestling | Men's At-Large | 3rd |
| Connor McMenamin | --- | Men's Track/XC | 3rd |
| Victoria Tachinski | --- | Women's Track/XC | 2nd |
| Ally Schlegel | F | Women's Soccer | 3rd |
| Makenna Marisa | G | Women's Basketball | 3rd |
| Collin Burkhart | --- | Men's Track/XC | 3rd |
| Peter Mangione | F | Men's Soccer | 3rd |
| Cori Dyke | M | Women's Soccer | 2nd |
| Kate Wiesner | D | Women's Soccer | 2nd |
| Kat Asman | GK | Women's Soccer | 3nd |
| Florence Cardon | --- | Women's Track/XC | 2nd |
| Tessa Janecke | Women's Hockey | Women's At-Large | 1st |
| Phia Gladieux | Field Hockey | Women's At-Large | 3rd |
| Michael Artlip | Men's Gymnastics | Men's At-Large | 1st |
| Levi Haines | Wrestling | Men's At-Large | 2nd |
CSC Sport Academic All-American of the Year
| Academic Year | Sport | Name | Position/Sport |
| 1986-87 | Men's At-Large | James Martin | Wrestling |
| 1988-89 | Men's At-Large | James Martin | Wrestling |
| 1993-94 | Men's At-Large | Byron Schneider | Volleyball |
| 1994-95 | Men's Basketball | John Amaechi | --- |
| 1998-99 | Women's Volleyball | Bonnie Bremner | S |
| 1999-00 | Women's Volleyball | Bonnie Bremner | S |
| 2002-03 | Women's Basketball | Kelly Mazzante | G |
| 2006-07 | Football | Paul Posluszny | LB |
| 2009-10 | Women's Volleyball | Megan Hodge | --- |
| 2013-14 | Women's Volleyball | Katie Slay | --- |
| 2014-15 | Men's At-Large | Matt Brown | Wrestling |
| 2020-21 | Women's Soccer | Kerry Abello | D |
| 2021-22 | Women's Soccer | Kerry Abello | D |
CSC Overall Academic All-American of the Year
| Academic Year | Sport | Name | Sport |
| 1988-89 | Men's At-Large | James Martin | Wrestling |
| 2014-15 | Men's At-Large | Matt Brown | Wrestling |