Isaiah Shayter · RHP · R/R · 6-2 · 190 · Elizabethtown, Pa./Elizabethtown Area HS
Chose Penn State over ECU, Kent State and Pitt
HIGH SCHOOL
Plays at Elizabethtown Area for head coach Jordan Higgins…Helped Elizabethtown Area to a state semifinals appearance in 2025...Named first-team all-state in Pennsylvania as a pitcher and infielder in 2025...Earned Team MVP honors…As a senior, made 14 appearances (12 starts). Went 8-3 with a 0.77 ERA in 63 innings. Recorded 107 strikeouts while allowing just seven earned runs and 21 walks. Held opponents to a .150 batting average and a 0.87 WHIP. At the plate, batted .385 with a .509 on-base percentage. Had 11 doubles, two homers, 24 RBI and 18 runs...As a junior, posted a 1.16 ERA and 37 strikeouts in 24 innings, while allowing a .143 average…As a sophomore, recorded a 1.25 ERA in 39 inning, while notching 51 strikeouts and a .161 opposing average…As a freshman, registered a 2.23 ERA in 31 innings and picked up 44 strikeouts…Tabbed as the No. 21 prospect and No. 2 RHP in Pennsylvania by Perfect Game…Ranked as the No. 18 prospect and No. 4 SS in PA by Prep Baseball Report…Also competed in football and wrestling…Played travel ball for Complete Game Academy.
PERSONAL
Son of Stephen Shayter and Marlana Brandt…Has a brother, Kamren…Father, Stephen, played baseball at Elizabethtown College…Undecided as a major.